Maria Voisin - Avon's puppet coroner?

category bristol | policing | news report author Monday April 02, 2012 19:56author by Tony Gosling Report this post to the editors

Few people know about or understand the reasons behind the sacking, in February 2011, of Avon Coroner Paul Forrest who was initially suspended in August 2008. The reason for the lack of public knowledge about his tortuous sacking process is that, at the behest of the Head of Legal Services and electoral returning officer at Bristol City Council Stephen McNamara, gagging clauses were included in the severence agreement with Forrest and other staff sacked from their jobs in the Avon Coroners' Office in Flax Bourton.

Despite being whistleblowers none of those dismissed are allowed to say anything to anyone about the circumstances of their sacking, or about any of their work at the Flax Bourton Coroners' Court so information has to be gathered instead from what is a plethora of press articles on the long-drawn-out and ugly bullying & sacking process.

Avon Coroners' Court is very difficult for many to travel to from Bristol, particularly by public transport. The infrequent buses from Bristol to Flax Bourton stop over a mile from the court which is situated 'in the middle of nowhere' and there are no signs to direct members of the public to it. The coroners court was formerly in Backfields, Bristol City Centre, and easily accessible very close to Bristol bus station ... but was moved inexplicably in 2004 and subsequently sold to the owners of the Lakota Night Club in Upper York Street.

Since the Norman invasion British coroners have been guaranteed independence from local government and everybody else. Indeed this independence is protected by law and they are supposed to be independently funded as a judicial service. The trouble began though when Bristol City Council took over the payroll service for the coroner and Bristol City Council have used that power to effectively control appointments in Avon Coroners Service, which is against the law.

The trouble got worse when then coroner Paul Forrest was branded "High-Handed and Aggressive" by Bristol City Council's legal team. He began to be told by officers of Bristol City Council what he was and wasn't allowed to say and how to do his job. This included making public statements in 2005 critical of his own service as he described "bodies piling up at Southmead Hospital mortuary" because of a lack of action which he had demanded and lack of funding from Bristol City Council.

Forrest was being told what to do by the council officers even though he was supposed to be independent. Many would consider this treatment as a form of 'constructive dismissal' or bullying and that a robust defence of his position was entirely appropriate.

As well as Bristol Coroner Maria Voisin, Assistant Deputy Coroner Terence Moore is also considered by many to be a 'puppet coroner' who is unlikely to find against establishment bodies such as Bristol City Council, Big Business and Avon and Somerset Police. The change of regime in the Bristol Coroners' Service has been described by one individual close to the process of putting new, non-independent minded coroners in place as "utterly crooked".

It has also been remarked that an avalanche of inquests where Bristol City Council and staff were implicated were dealt with by the Avon coroner as soon as Paul Forrest was out of the way and that once these cases were eventually heard little or no blame, criminal or financial liability was laid at Bristol City Council's door.

One such case was that of Dennis Pring whose dead body laid under a sofa in a Bristol City Council flat decomposing for ten years despite repeated warning calls from neighbours and visits from council staff failed to detect the rotting corpse.

Related Link:
author by Louis XIVpublication date Mon Apr 02, 2012 22:17Report this post to the editors

La Voisin... ah yes, I watched her inauguration. She has no credibility, just ambition. Her namesake in the 1670s was a professional poisoner who sold poisons on the black market to the French aristocracy so that they could get rid of anyone in the way of their devious plots.

An amusing irony perhaps...

author by b-lawyerpublication date Wed Jul 18, 2012 12:21Report this post to the editors

Ms Voisin's probably the most able lawyer I've ever met, and certainly one of the steeliest. To call her a puppet is to underestimate that aspect of her in an alarming fashion. Whilst we can't know precisely what led to her hiring, her talent for the job suggests it was done on merit.

If there was a backlog of work that got cleared once she was in place, I would suggest that tells you more about the efficiency issues the old regime had than anything else. If information on this topic is being gathered from those who lost their jobs, I would further suggest that they may not be the most impartial sources (for perfectly legitimate and understandable reasons no doubt, but the critique of what they have to say still stands).

author by Janepublication date Thu Nov 01, 2012 09:02Report this post to the editors

My family have had personal experience of how she works. Ignoring highly important evidence in the Coroner's court supplied by eminent professors and instructing a dubious expert witness who was at odds with other witnesses from the medical profession left us speechless. One day she will get her come uppance I think!

2001-2013 Bristol Indymedia. Unless otherwise stated by the author, all content is free for non-commercial reuse, reprint, and rebroadcast, on the net and elsewhere. Opinions are those of the contributors and are not necessarily endorsed by Bristol Indymedia. Disclaimer | Privacy